Switch to switchgrass best option for Tennessee
published: November 09 2009 05:14 PM updated:: November 10 2009 04:03 PM

Imagine a place where farmers could grow a specific type of crop that could be processed to produce a product that people need to drive their cars.

That place is Tennessee. That crop is switchgrass. That product is ethanol.

On October 23, Dr. Kelly Tiller, as associate professor of agricultural economics, delivered a presentation, "The Economics of Switchgrass to Ethanol," at the UT Science Forum.

The Southeast, which lacks the necessary sources for strong solar, geothermal or wind energy, has been called the "Saudi Arabia of Swithgrass." One acre of switchgrass produces 1,000 gallons of ethanol. Kelly Tiller, associate professor of agricultural economicsOne acre of switchgrass produces 1,000 gallons of ethanol, says Tiller.

"It [switchgrass] grows fast, capturing lots of solar energy and turning it into lots of chemical energy- cellulose-that can be liquefied, gasified, or burned directly," according to an Oak Ridge National Laboratory Web site source. "It also reaches deep into the soil for water, and uses the water it finds very efficiently."

Though switchgrass has its advantages, Tiller did not hesitate to point out the disadvantages.

The challenge lies in persuading farmers to grow switchgrass in the current market where there's almost no demand for the crop.

As part of the $70.5 million state commitment and the collaborative efforts of DuPont Danisco Ethanol, LLC, the University of Tennessee Research Foundation and Genera Energy, LLC, farmers are provided switchgrass seed, technical expertise and a $450 incentive per year for three years to grow and produce switchgrass.

In 2008, 723 acres of switchgrass were contracted on 16 farms.

"Seventy-five percent of our farmers in 2008 asked for additional acreage in 2009," said Tiller, president and CEO of Genera Energy. "That's a fairly strong indication of success."

More than half of the state commitment, $40.7 million to be exact will go to constructing the biorefinery, where the switchgrass to ethanol conversion takes place.

In her presentation, Dr. Tiller explained the process. First, the switchgrass, wood chips and other biomass arrive at the biorefinery. Then, steam and acid separate shredded biomass into cellulose, hemicelluloses (less complex than cellulose) and lignin ("liquid wood"). The cellulose and hemicelluloses are broken down into sugars, while the lingin is removed for other products. After the yeast turns the sugars into alcohol, distillation removes water and increases the alcohol's potency as a fuel. Finally, the cellulosic ethanol ("grassoline") is transported to consumer outlets.

According to the Genera Energy Web site, collaborators expect to produce ethanol from the biorefinery by the end of 2009.

The economics of switchgrass and ethanol can perhaps best be summarized by the following statistic that Tiller gave the audience - for every dollar spent at the pump for gasoline, 80 percent goes out of the state. For every dollar spent at the pump for cellulosic ethanol, zero percent goes out of the state.

 

 

Editor: Miriam Kramer

Quick Switchgrass Facts

  • The net energy output of switchgrass is about 20 times better than corn's.
  • Results of a recent USDA-ARS study showed that the average overall production cost across 5 production years was about $68.56 per metric ton. The researchers concluded that "substantial quantities of switchgrass could have been produced in the region at about $50 per metric ton." This would translate to about 0.13 cents per liter of ethanol.
  • Switchgrass is native to North America, and estimated yields vary from 500 to 1,000 gallons of ethanol per acre.
  • Test plots of switchgrass at Auburn University have produced up to 15 tons of dry biomass per acre, and five-year yields average 11.5 tons-enough to make 1,150 gallons of ethanol per acre each year.
  • Switchgrass can be cut and baled with conventional mowers and balers.
  • Because switchgrass removes carbon dioxide from the air as it grows, it has the potential to slow the buildup of greenhouse gas in Earth's atmosphere.
  • Drawbacks include the lack of breeding history compared to crops like corn, a year to establish the field, the need for nitrogen fertilizers - although lower requirement for fertilizers than corn - and the current lack of a switchgrass infrastructure.

Source: Biofuels Wiki, hosted and maintained by the Biofuels Center at North Carolina

Ad
Ad
About| Archives| Contact| Courses| Staff| Search