In the midst of a drought that has plagued the southeastern United States for more than a year, many legal struggles have sparked between states in various attempts to improve their own water source.
In what could be the most controversial move yet, members of the Georgia state senate recently drafted a resolution to redefine the Tennessee-Georgia boundary, moving the border approximately one mile north of its current location.
Sen. David Shafer and Rep. Harry Geisinger introduced a bill to set up a commission that would designate the states with "definite and true boundary lines."
Tennessee Gov. Phil Bredesen's initial reaction was similar to many residents of border towns. He replied to an Associated Press reporter who mentioned the topic by saying "This is a joke, right?"
With an extreme water shortage in north Georgia, the legislation is far from a joke. The state senators who back the bill believe Georgians should claim their right to the waters of the Tennessee River.
If they really do try to pull this off, we will do whatever we have to do to defend ourselves. My constituents have no desire to live in Georgia. Marion County Mayor, Howell MossThe bill points to a survey conducted in 1818, claiming that the placement of the border markers was conducted with cheap, unsuitable instruments.
According to the bill, modern mapping techniques indicate that Georgia's border was erroneously placed one mile south of the 35th parallel, the line that was mandated by Congress originally.
"If they really do try to pull this off, we will do whatever we have to do to defend ourselves," said Howell Moss, Marion County mayor, in an interview with the Los Angeles Times. "My constituents have no desire to live in Georgia."
The reason politicians in the Peach State are just now beginning a fight for the land is simple. The Tennessee River has a flow of water about 15 times greater than the Chattahoochee river, which is currently the main natural water source serving Metro Atlanta.
The bill would commission legislators from Georgia, Tennessee and North Carolina to investigate claims that the border is actually 5,600 feet north, which would mean that the Tennessee River cuts into a corner of Georgia and could help appease the state's crisis.
While the bill would likely be struck down by the Supreme Court if passed through the state's senate, the region will likely be forced to share water with Georgia in the long run unless an end to the drought comes soon.Despite winter rains and occasional snow that seemingly appeased the dry conditions, the desperation among officials in every state of the region is only growing stronger.
According to a report included in the Georgia Senate's attempt to investigate the historical placement of the borders, scientists tracking long-term weather trends expect the drought to continue and possibly worsen when warm weather returns.
"The rain pretty much belies what we'll see in late spring," said Georgia State Rep. Lynn Smith, chairwoman of the House Natural Resources and Environment Committee.
Rep. Smith called for a special committee meeting last week with Dr. Carol Couch, director of the Georgia Environmental Protection Division.
"The drought conditions in Georgia have progressively worsened for the past year," Couch said.
She also pointed out that winter and early spring are "the time of rain in this state [Georgia.] Wherein our reservoirs are replenished, water tables are replenished."
It will rain. That doesn't mean the drought is over. The drought conditions in Georgia have progressively worsened for the past year Dr. Carol Crouch, Georgia EPD
"It will rain. That doesn't mean the drought is over." She said data collected by her agency "indicate that all of the state is in some level of abnormal weather conditions."
One issue that has plagued Georgia is the Army Corps of Engineers: the Corps is required to take 20 feet of water out of Lake Seminole, another major water source in the state, to support endangered species in Florida.
Gov. Sonny Perdue has directly blamed the Corps for causing the water crisis, and Georgia has taken action to reduce flows, though unsuccessful to this point.
Until rain appeases the situation or states suffering through the water crisis begin working together, outlandish lawsuits like the one calling for the change of a centuries old border could become commonplace.
"Other hazards tend to pull people together," said Michael Hayes, director of the National Drought Mitigation Center at the University of Nebraska, in an interview with the AP. "With a drought, because it's a limited resource, it tends to drive people apart."



Comments
Poo Radley commented, on February 12, 2008 at 1:28 a.m.:
Georgia can suck it. Why should Tennesseeans give up our water because of atlanta's unresponsable growth. Their are much more intelligent ways of going about this than what they are proposing. Did they ever consider just asking for some water? I'd much rather just share the river with them than have part of Chattanooga be annexed by Georgia. Tennessee has much better laws and is more forward thinking than those Georgians.
thirsty commented, on February 12, 2008 at 9:09 a.m.:
They've got to be kidding. The problem has two key elements. First, of course, is the drought. Second, really is the law that requires the Corps. to drain the lake to the endangered species in FL. GA has all kinds of watering restrictions and businesses like landscapers and family owned car washes without the expensive equipment to recycle water are going under. There is talk of not being able to open pools this summer or parks like White Water or water rides at six flags. That's ok because you do what you have to. Georgia is draining their water to save endangerd wildlife in FL & AL. To top it off though, FL and AL don't have any watering restrictions - they haven't lost jobs, they haven't lost their expensive plants and they don't have to drain their lakes to water their precious wildlife (I think its mollusks). When do people become more important than snails? Back to the original point though. Now with this move to take TN's water just makes them look stupid. It's a real problem and they have made it look like a joke by trying to solve it with a silly solution.
Aunt Tiddy Tat commented, on February 12, 2008 at 3:36 p.m.:
Georgia doesen't own the federal water reservoies the tax payers do...all of us.
Start taking water, in large amounts, from the Tenn.River, then what happens to TVA, the power plants, the Tenn/Tom. water way, that runs partly through Mississippi that many things vital to the Space/Military programs use.(and other things shipped down it)Whatever they are...!
Lowering the level of the river could be diaster...I'm not going to worry about the fresh water mollusks...etc./flora etc...important as they are.
Alabama does have under ground rivers taping into them to share with Georgia is an expessive matter and will take time...maybe Georgia could help out. Sister states should be able to work things out...together.
Janet commented, on February 12, 2008 at 11:15 p.m.:
If you argue that GA doesn't own federal water then you have to argue that neither does TN. Still, its not a good idea. I live in GA & its so stupid its embarassing.
AL & FL should use its own water if it wants to save its mollusks. GA's endangered species are going without water now too. They should also be on strict watering restrictions if they think for a second they have a right to take anybody's water.
Mae S. commented, on February 26, 2008 at 6:18 p.m.:
To "thirsty": I live in Monrovia, AL just west of Huntsville and near the TN River. We are not allowed to wash vehicles at all. Our watering is restricted to flower beds and vegetable gardens, but we can only water between midnight and 4:00 a.m. We are not allowed to water our lawns and most of us have had brown, dead lawns for over two years. Many of us do not have watering systems and must get up in the middle of the night to water our gardens. Birmingham residents were not allowed to water anything at all. Lawns and expensive landscaping has died.
Ronni commented, on February 27, 2008 at 7:52 p.m.:
Thank you.
This made an amazing current event article for U.S History.
confusedtennessean commented, on March 1, 2008 at 1:35 a.m.:
Ok - maybe I just don't get it....endangered florida wildlife is entitled to water before endangered georgia residents.....
Where is the logic? GA corp of engineers need to revisit this issue, as long as the drought is on, the water should be off.
Tennessee border residents will continue to protest as long as georgia persues this matter - if we wanted to live in geogia, we would have bought a house 1 mile down the road. :(
cat lover commented, on March 15, 2008 at 1:05 p.m.:
I'm scared about the drought right now.But I heard Lake Lanier is doing a good good getting rain so we don't have to worry that much.I also heard they have over 50,00,00 gallons of water.So why don't they put that water in Lake Lanier RIGHT NOW!!!!!
Post a comment